For the first time in more than 10 years, defense is an issue in a Presidential election campaign. Both sides agree that a defense increase is necessary, but they differ enormously in their recollections of where the shortage came from.
"The current Administration inherited a military ready for the dangers and challenges facing our nation," said Republican George W. Bush Aug. 21. "The next President will inherit a military in decline."
The next day, Democrat Al Gore replied that "these past eight years, as a member of the National Security Council, I have worked to reverse the decline in defense spending. ... I'm proud that we finally reversed the defense cuts begun in the previous Administration with a safe, long-term increase in defense spending."
The New York Times then informed us that, "adjusted for inflation, the United States still spends about 95 percent as much for defense as it did during the Cold War, though it now faces sharply reduced threats."
The things you read in the newspapers are breathtaking, but some assertions go further afield. Pentagon gadfly Chuck Spinney is circulating a chart that depicts the current defense budget as almost four times as large as during the Vietnam War. (Spinney leaps to his conclusion by ignoring the effects of 525 percent cumulative inflation since 1968.)
Here's what really happened. Figures are fiscal year Department of Defense budget authority, and to allow comparison, all are expressed in constant Fiscal 2001 dollars.
The Vietnam War budgets peaked at $400.6 billion in 1968. A steady decline followed, and it did not stop until the ensuing "hollow force" had become a national scandal. From 1975 to 1980, budgets floundered between $273 billion and $297 billion. Airplanes stood idle on the ramp for want of parts. Veteran service members fled the ranks. It was this brief, sorry period that the New York Times chose for its comparison. The present defense budget is about the same as the hollow force budgets.
The correction came with the "Reagan Recovery," which peaked at $436.4 billion in 1985. By 1986, the Gramm-Rudman-Hollings movement to reduce the federal deficit was in full swing, and Congress declared President Reagan's defense budget proposal "DOA," or Dead on Arrival. After that, the defense budget dropped more each year until 1999.
President Bush inherited a defense program that was already down by 10 percent. Mainly because the Cold War had ended-but also because of continuing Gramm-Rudman-Hollings pressures--the Bush Administration devised the "Base Force." The plan was to gradually cut force structure and personnel strength by 25 percent below Cold War levels. Opposition leaders in Congress wanted even stiffer reductions. The final Bush defense budget was $318.4 billion in 1993.
Two months after taking office, the Clinton Administration proclaimed an additional cut of $214 billion, spread out over six years. The announcement was made without calculation of feasibility or impact, so the Pentagon hastily launched the "Bottom Up Review" in search of a credible defense program that would fit the budget that had been declared.
No such solution could be found, so the reductions actually implemented were somewhat less severe. Even so, President Clinton proposed seven defense budget cuts in a row. And each year, Congress appropriated more than he requested.
The low point came in 1998, at $277.2 billion. The next year, the Administration announced a $110 billion budget increase spread out over six years.
Part of the purported increase hung on gimmicks, counting adjustments, and economic assumptions, and most of it did not fall due until after the turn of the century, in effect an IOU written on a future Administration. Clinton's 2001 budget proposal, submitted last January, was for $291.1 billion.
Whoever wins the Presidential election should have that engraved on the insides of his eyelids before he moves into the White House.
See what senior leaders had to say at AFA's Air Warfare Symposium in Orlando, Fla.
Find out what senior Air Force and industry leaders had to say at AFA's Air Warfare Symposium.
AFA's Air Warfare Symposium kicked off Wednesday and runs through Friday. Follow Air Force Magazine's coverage of the show online and via social media by following us on Twitter,
Flickr, or by using
Tweets by @AirForceMag